Natalie Anderson – San Juan del Sur (Season 29)
Her twin sister was the first contestant voted off the island, but Natalie went on to win the whole darn thing. Now she gets a chance to do it again! (No twin sister this time, though.)
Jeremy Collins – Cambodia — Second Chance (Season 31)
Jeremy won his season of Survivor in a unanimous vote — chances are that won’t happen again, but who knows? At least he won’t have to worry about sending his wife to Exile Island again.