“I will say, Lindsay’s a beautiful girl. Like, you’re drinking, having fun, I’m single…” he reasoned. “And they say date your best friend. Usually, that goes well.”
At BravoCon a few months ago, the twosome also hinted that they weren’t necessarily sober during those sexual encounters. “There were a few mornings when I woke up and didn’t even know what happened the night before,” Carl confessed to ET.
Meanwhile, co-star Kyle Cooke claimed he knew it was only a matter of time before Carl and Lindsay hooked up, but was still shocked when it actually happened.
“When I found out… it was the night before we were headed out to the house,” he explained to People. “I almost got hit by a car because I think I stopped in the middle of the street like, ‘What?!'”
New episodes of Summer House air Wednesdays at 9 p.m. ET on Bravo.