The redhead grew up going to church with Aspyn, but even though his future wife had a crush on him as a teen, the two didn’t start dating until after college.
“We went different directions until a rally some of my family attended in Utah, where we both happened to be,” Aspyn told People magazine in an interview. “My dad’s brother asked what ever happened between us, which was nothing, because neither of us did anything about it. So I decided to call him.”
Mitch popped the question in December 2017 during a trip to Seattle. “I was so happy, I said yes immediately and pulled him up to kiss me before he could even put on the ring,” Aspyn recalled.